ABS vs Polycarbonate Suitcase: Which One Should You Buy?

Choosing the right suitcase is more than just picking a color or size. For frequent travelers, the material of your suitcase can make or break your journey. Two of the most commonly compared materials are ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) and polycarbonate. They may look similar at first glance, but they behave very differently under pressure - literally and figuratively.

👉 Check Out Our Aqua Vista Collection

Let’s break it down with a relatable situation: imagine you're at baggage claim. The conveyor belt starts rolling, and you spot your suitcase - cracked at the corner with your clothes peeking out. If you’ve ever been in this situation (or want to avoid it), the choice between ABS and polycarbonate becomes more important than ever.

In this article, we’ll dive deep into the differences, advantages, and drawbacks of both materials so you can make a smarter, stress-free travel investment.

👉 Check Out Our Midnight Voyager Collection

1. What Are ABS and Polycarbonate?

ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) is a thermoplastic polymer known for its light weight and cost-effectiveness. It's widely used in consumer electronics, automotive parts, and budget luggage.

Polycarbonate, on the other hand, is a tougher and more flexible material often found in high-performance gear like safety goggles, riot shields, and premium travel luggage. It offers greater impact resistance and resilience.

Feature Comparison: ABS vs Polycarbonate Suitcase

• Weight: ABS suitcases are lighter, while polycarbonate ones are slightly heavier.

• Cost: ABS is budget-friendly; polycarbonate is more expensive.

• Durability: ABS offers moderate durability, whereas polycarbonate provides high durability.

• Flexibility: ABS has low flexibility, while polycarbonate is highly flexible.

• Scratch Resistance: ABS has lower scratch resistance compared to polycarbonate, which is more resistant.

• Weather Resistance: ABS has fair weather resistance, whereas polycarbonate offers excellent protection.

2. Durability and Strength: Will It Survive the Trip?

When it comes to surviving the abuse of airline baggage handlers, polycarbonate wins hands down.

• ABS is rigid and more prone to cracking upon impact. If dropped from a height or struck hard, it can break or fracture, especially around corners and edges.

• Polycarbonate is engineered to flex on impact and then return to its original shape. This flexibility gives it a strong advantage for air travel, especially when your suitcase is tossed under heavy luggage.

A polycarbonate suitcase might dent, but it rarely breaks. This makes it ideal for frequent flyers or international travelers who can’t afford to replace bags often.

3. Weight and Portability: Which One Is Easier to Carry?

ABS luggage is lighter. If weight is your top concern - say you're traveling with strict carry-on weight limits - then ABS can be appealing.

However, polycarbonate luggage manufacturers have significantly reduced the weight of their products over time using advanced molding techniques. While they are slightly heavier than ABS models, the difference is often only a few hundred grams.

So if you’re looking for ultra-light packing and occasional use, ABS works. But for a balance of strength and portability, polycarbonate still holds up well.

🧭 Explore the Nomad Explorer Collection

4. Cost Consideration: Is It Worth Paying More?

One of the biggest reasons people choose ABS is the price tag.

• ABS suitcases are significantly cheaper and widely available in the low to mid-range market. They are ideal for casual or infrequent travelers.

• Polycarbonate suitcases come at a premium but justify their cost through longer lifespan and superior protection.

For instance, an ABS suitcase might cost $40–$70 and last 1–2 years with moderate use. A polycarbonate suitcase, priced at $100–$250, could easily last 5+ years, depending on usage.

If you travel just once or twice a year, ABS might suffice. But for business travelers, families on long trips, or digital nomads, polycarbonate is the better investment in the long run.

5. Aesthetics and Design Variety

Both ABS and polycarbonate suitcases come in a wide range of colors, textures, and finishes. However, polycarbonate bags often have a sleeker, more premium look due to the quality of the material and finishes.

In addition:

• Polycarbonate luggage can feature advanced designs like brushed textures or matte finishes that reduce visible scratches.

• ABS luggage tends to show wear and tear faster, especially scratches, dents, and fading from sunlight exposure.

So if visual appeal and long-term aesthetics matter to you, polycarbonate has the edge.

6. Real-World Usage: Which Suitcase Is Right for You?

Here’s how to decide, based on your lifestyle:

Choose ABS if:

• You're an occasional traveler (1–2 trips a year).

• You want a light suitcase on a tight budget.

• You prefer buying new luggage every few years.

Choose Polycarbonate if:

• You travel frequently or internationally.

• You carry valuable or delicate items.

• You want a suitcase that lasts longer and offers better protection.

Example: Mauli, a college student, travels home twice a year and goes on an annual trip with friends. For her, a $60 ABS suitcase makes sense. 

But Mehul, a consultant flying weekly for work, relies on a durable polycarbonate model that protects his laptop and suits.

Conclusion: The Material Makes a Difference

In the debate of ABS vs polycarbonate suitcases, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It boils down to your travel habits, budget, and expectations from your luggage.

ABS is great for budget-conscious, light users. It does the job - but not without limitations. Polycarbonate, though more expensive, pays off with added durability, flexibility, and peace of mind.

💬 Before your next trip, ask yourself: Do I want a suitcase that lasts a season - or one that travels the world with me?

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Which suitcase material is stronger: ABS or polycarbonate?

Polycarbonate is stronger and more flexible than ABS, making it better at withstanding impact during travel.

Are ABS suitcases lightweight?

Yes, ABS suitcases are lightweight and ideal for travelers who prioritize low weight over durability.

Do polycarbonate suitcases crack easily?

No, polycarbonate suitcases are highly resistant to cracking and usually dent instead of breaking.

Is it worth paying more for a polycarbonate suitcase?

Yes, if you travel frequently, the added durability and lifespan of polycarbonate justify the higher cost.

Which suitcase is better for international travel?

Polycarbonate is better suited for international travel due to its durability and impact resistance.

Do ABS suitcases scratch easily?

Yes, ABS suitcases tend to scratch and scuff more easily compared to polycarbonate ones.

Can polycarbonate suitcases handle extreme temperatures?

Yes, polycarbonate performs well in both hot and cold conditions, unlike ABS which may become brittle.

How long do ABS and polycarbonate suitcases last?

ABS may last 1–2 years with moderate use, while polycarbonate can last 5 or more years with frequent use.